Was king john really a failure

He manages to surrender his realm to the pope and ends up facing a huge baronial rebellion, a civil war and a war with France. John's greatest weakness was an inability to trust. Henry II married Eleanor here inand its surrender by the Lusignans marked the end of Angevin power in Aquitaine.

The new king also had enough respect for John's troublemaking tendencies to ban him from England for three years whilst he Richard went on crusade. To raise the massive armies and fleets this enterprise would require, he wrung unprecedented sums of money from England. He had a motherless childhood, as Eleanor of Aquitaine was under house arrest at the royal castle in Salisbury.

Unable to pay his mercenaries because of the extravagance of his way of life, he was eventually forced to abandon Ireland in September, blaming Hugh de Lacy for obstructionism.

King John and Richard I: Brothers and Rivals

Many people argue that King John was a greedy, weak and incompetent King. Morris, who can be relied on to add the piquant detail, writes: Henry the Young King had been crowned King of England inbut was not given any formal powers by his father; he was also promised Normandy and Anjou as part of his future inheritance.

This was a mistake. The reasons for their views depend on what aspect of King John they study.

Why is King John the classic villain?

Lusignan - ancestral seat of the Lusignans in Poitou. John proved to be a disaster and within six months he was sent home. Such is the general background that led to Magna Carta, a charge-sheet aimed squarely at King John and his many acts of misgovernment. The challenge for the modern historian is to mobilise a coherent narrative that, like John, is always on the go, and yet to resist it drifting into a procession of matchstick figures all blurring together in a medieval mist.

He had the dash and flair to risk all on the most slender of odds. He remains, for all the wealth of day-to-day correspondence, a flitting, opaque figure: He knighted the year-old John, gave him an army of knights and a treasury, and sent him to Ireland to take charge of the situation.

This guaranteed the people of England rights that the king could not go back on. By comparison with Richard, then, John has been seen as a weedy little tick. He was prepared to bury the hatchet and put his faith in even his most inveterate enemies and he understood that in the realpolitik of the day, you had to give in order to receive.

By contrast, his brother Richard has been seen by his contemporaries, and by later historians, as a superstar - his nickname, the 'Lionheart', says it all.

Was king john really a failure King John is one of the most well-known figures in history because he was the son of King Henry and his brother was Richard the lionheart. Many people think that john was a failure to the throne.

However, some people disagree with this view of john. Feb 17,  · The story of King John is a story of failure - he was the last of the Angevin kings, the one who failed to hold onto his territory in western France, lost.

John, King of England

History Essays - King John. Print Reference this. Published: 23rd March, is one of failure.

King John: the most evil monarch in Britain's history

Bysix years into his reign, only a fragment of the vast Angevin empire acquired by Henry II remained, John was embroiled in quarreling with the Pope over the appointment of the Archbishop of Canterbury, and was also forced to sign the. Was King John Really a Failure Essay The question as to whether King John was really the worst king ever, stills seems to be a topic of much controversy amongst historians, as they have not yet come to an exact decision on which side of the argument to deem as the truth.

John (24 December – 19 October ), also known as John Lackland, was King of England from until his death in John lost the Duchy of Normandy and most of his other French lands to King Philip II of France, resulting in the collapse of the Angevin Empire and contributing to the subsequent growth in power of the French Capetian.

King John and Richard I: Brothers and Rivals

King John was King of England from to He lost many of his family’s Angevin lands on the continent and was forced to concede numerous rights to his barons in the Magna Carta, which has led to John being considered a colossal failure.

Was king john really a failure
Rated 5/5 based on 9 review
BBC - History - British History in depth: King John and Richard I: Brothers and Rivals